Robust Procurement Design
Prof. Alessandro Pavan
The paper studies the design of procurement contracts in environments where the buyer faces uncertainty over the product’s demand and the supplier’s cost. The buyer has a belief but does not fully trust it. They first identify all worst-case optimal mechanisms, which deliver the largest payoff guarantee over a set of plausible demand and cost functions. They then select the mechanism that maximizes their expected payoff (under their beliefs) over such a restricted set. We show that robustness calls for an increase in the output asked of the least efficient suppliers and a reduction of the one asked of suppliers with an intermediate cost. The analysis also identifies conditions under which price regulation is superior to quantity regulation and delivers a few policy recommendations.